Daily Dicta: Cheers to the 2017 Litigators of the Week Winners

[caption id="attachment_846" align="aligncenter" width="620"]

silver-trophy[/caption] From fighting the travel ban to negotiating Michael Flynn’s plea deal to suing the DJ who groped Taylor Swift, the lawyers featured each Friday as our Litigators of the Week have been in the middle of the year’s biggest stories.Each Friday, we bestow the title on the lawyer or team with the most noteworthy win from the prior seven days. Looking back at the 2017 winners, they’re a who’s-who of the top litigators in the United States—the most creative, successful courtroom advocates practicing today. The most-honored firm? Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, which won the award five times. As for individual lawyers, three of them won Litigator of the Week twice in 2017: Neal Katyalof Hogan Lovells (who also took The American Lawyer’s grand prize for litigator of the year) and Kirkland & Ellis partners Craig Primis and K. Winn Allen. In all, we named 76 lawyers Litigator of the Week (some weeks, the award was shared by co-counsel). However, only 12 of them were women, a reminder that women continue to be under-represented as first-chair litigators. Still, it’s an improvement over last year, when only eight winners were women. (Curious how this year’s winners stacked up against 2016? See 2016 in Review: Litigators of the Week, Take a Bow).Here’s a chronological look back at the 2017 champions, whose profiles tell the story of the year in litigation.January 6Stamina Pays for David Boies and Carl Goldfarb in 14-year fightAfter 14 years and two trips to the U.S. Supreme Court, Boies, Schiler & Flexner partners David Boies and Carl Goldfarb secured a $100 million settlement from Halliburton.January 13A Rare Feat in a Billion Dollar Drug Fight In a case with billions of dollars at stake, McDermott Will & Emery partners William G. Gaede III and Sarah C. Columbia won a rare post-trial ruling for Amgen Inc. that booted a rival's drug from the market. January 20The Lawyer Who Won Chelsea Manning Her Freedom When Chelsea Manning's 35-year prison sentence was commuted, it send shock waves among internet commentators, monopolized several news cycles and solidified Nancy Hollander's reputation as a rock-star criminal defense lawyer. An Exceptional Carve-Out in VW LitigationArent Fox partner Russell McRory got a win when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reinstated a case he brought against Volkswagen—and he wasn’t about to let a bigger problem wipe out his victory. February 3 A Major Defense Win in Insider Trading Case In one of the first cases to go to trial since the Supreme Court lowered the bar for prosecutors in insider trading cases, Goodwin Procter partners Grant Fondo and Derek Cohen handed the feds a big defeat February 10 Travel Ban First Responders, Take a BowWorking in an atmosphere rife with uncertainty, misinformation and often devoid of communication by government officials, lawyers including Shaimaa Hussein of Willkie Farr & Gallagher and Mayer Brown partners Paul Hughes and Andrew Pincus, surrendered sleep, prepared for every contingency and, in some cases, went with their gut to bring their clients safely to the United States.February 17A Look at the Lawyers Who Won Key Battle in Water WarKirkland & Ellis partners Craig Primis, K. Winn Allen and Devora Allon made it impossible for Florida to build its case against Georgia in an epic battle over water rights.February 24Covington Team Takes Fight to the Feds to Make Clients WholeCovington & Burling’sBenjamin Razi and Bruce Baird persuaded a New York jury that the federal government should return 47 luxury cars and $3.4 million in cash seized from a Chinese couple running an import-export business. March 3 Knocking out the Last of the Enron Suits Some winds take time. Sullivan & Cromwell partners Robert Giuffra Jr. and Brendan Cullen know that for sure—it took them almost 15 years to win dismissal of a would-be class action against UBS stemming from Enron’s collapse. March 10How New Lawyers Broke J&J's Losing Streak in Talc TrialsProskauer Rose partners Bart Williams and Manuel Cachán scored first defense win in the talcum powder litigation for Johnson & Johnson.March 17The Hogan Associate (and Partner) Who Knocked Out the Travel BanHogan Lovells associate Colleen Roh Sinzdak shared argument time with partner Neal Katyal in challenging the executive order on immigration in the U.S. District Court of Hawaii.March 24When Insurers Refused to Pay Verizon’s $48M Legal Bill, This Lawyer Hit BackRobin Cohen, the head of McKool Smith’s insurance recovery practice, forced a group of insurers to reimburse Verizon for fending off a failed $14 billion lawsuit.March 31How a Steptoe Team Got Their Client Off the Hook in Pay-to-Play CaseReid Weingarten and Brian Heberlig of Steptoe & Johnson had four boxes full of evidence meant to destroy the credibility of Pennsylvania's former treasurer on the witness stand. Turns out, they didn't need to open a single box.April 7This Hogan Team Beat Back a $100 Million Class ActionHogan Lovells partners Craig Hoover and Adam Levin defeated a class action against Anthem Inc. by 87,000 former employees and retirees of the state of Connecticut.April 14The Brains Behind BlackBerry’s $815M BlowoutFor a trial lawyer, sometimes backing away from a fight is the smartest move to make. That was the lesson that Sullivan & Cromwell partner Garrard Beeney said stuck with him as he argued his way to an $814.9 million arbitration win for BlackBerry.April 21An Appellate Attorney Fends Off Honda in a $55M FightSolo practitioner Howard J. Bashman, author of the appellate blog “How Appealing,” got a $55 million award affirmed for a man who was paralyzed during a rollover accident.April 28From Zero to Hero in Seven DaysIt all comes back to square one. That's how Gibson Dunn litigator Theodore “Ted” Boutrous Jr. describes his strategy for handling appeals—and it helped Travelers Insurance dodge a $36 million bullet.May 5Going for the Jugular in Blood Thinner BellwetherA federal jury in New Orleans deliberated for less than two hours before coming back with a defense win in the first bellwether trial over the blood thinner Xarelto. That's a bona fide slam dunk--even for lead defense counsel Beth Wilkinson of Wilkinson Walsh + Eskovitz.May 12Shutting Down a $2 Billion Case Against Intel, AgainYou might say WilmerHale's William Lee and Joseph Mueller were in a good position heading into trial in Delaware on behalf of Intel Corp. The day it began, the judge compared their opponent's patent case to someone “floating off into the inky blackness of space with no hope of survival or rescue.”May 19A Giant of the Plaintiffs Bar—and a Giant SettlementCohen Milstein Sellers & Toll partner Joseph Sellers just won approval of a major settlement in a decades-old discrimination class action, for what he hopes is the last time.May 26When Your Client is a Retired Judge, You Better Bring Your A GameLong & Levit partners Joseph McMonigle and Jessica MacGregor defended JAMS and one of its neutrals over resume-padding charges.June 2A Big-League Double Play for This Gibson Dunn LitigatorAndrew Tulumello co-chairs Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher's sports law practice, so he's familiar with the term “double play.” He pulled one off this week, bringing home two big victories for his clients, including a Supreme Court win.June 9Shooting the Moon for SpaceXFor the second time in the past eight months, Orrick’s Lynne Hermle convinced a Los Angeles jury to side with Elon Musk-led SpaceX in a lawsuit brought by a disgruntled former employee.June 16No Complaints from Kannon ShanmugamIt has been an eventful spring for Williams & Connolly partner Kannon Shanmugam. In April, his wife Vicki gave birth to their third son, Henry. The U.S. Supreme Court delivered two other bundles of joy: victories in both the cases he argued this term. June 23Practice Makes Perfect for This Hogan Lovells StarHogan Lovells partner Neal Katyal scored a game changing win in a SCOTUS case that fundamentally alters the growing practice of mass tort litigation--starting right now. How'd he do it? Hint: “It's not like I sit in my room and read the briefs.”June 30Distilling a $350M Trade Secrets Fight Down to the Essential FactsTo win a defense verdict in a $350 million trade secrets fight between the world's two largest essential oil companies, Ballard Spahr partner Mark Gaylord first had to convince a Utah judge that the case boiled down to simple contract dispute.July 7Playing the Long Game for Victims of TerrorismStroock & Stroock & Lavan partner James Bernard led a fight to recover more than $1 billion in assets for creditors who obtained favorable rulings from U.S. courts for losses suffered in Iran-backed attacks.July 14Quinn Emanuel's $25 Billion ManFollowing a string of successful mortgage-backed securities cases against most of the banking industry, Philippe Selendy of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan notched another achievement this week.July 21When the Feds Went Too Far, This Willkie Lawyer Hit BackFor a criminal defense lawyer, there's no better feeling than winning exoneration for a deserving client. Just ask Willkie Farr & Gallagher partner Michael Schachter.July 28A Jury ‘Thriller’ for a Music LegendVeteran Texas litigator Mike McKool of McKool Smith calls the breach of contract case pitting producer Quincy Jones against MJJ Productions and the estate of pop superstar Michael Jackson “one of the most enjoyable I've ever handled.”August 4In Terrorism Case, the Long View Paid OffIn Stuart Newberger's legal practice, patience is essential. So when the Crowell & Moring partner logged a significant win in a terrorism suit against Sudan before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, he shrugged off the fact that it came 17 years after his clients first came to him.August 11When the Feds Say ‘Uncle’ in a Fraud CaseHaynes and Boone partner David Siegal beat back a securities fraud case against international financier Benjamin Wey when the feds abandoned their case over evidence issues.August 18Taylor Swift’s Lawyer Tells All!Forgive the tabloid headline. Venable partner J. Douglas Baldridge is actually quite discreet when discussing his famous client. But he litigated under a blinding spotlight.August 25This Huge Talc Verdict is One for the Record Books–But It Almost Didn't Happen at AllMark Robinson of Robinson Calcagnie Inc. and Allen Smith of The Smith Law Firm won a $417 million verdict in the first talcum powder trial in California.September 1Grabbing the Prize After the Prize FightO’Melveny & Myers partners Daniel Petrocelli and Jeffrey Barker scored a total knockout of dozens of class actions brought over a 2015 bout dubbed the “Fight of the Century.”September 8A Slap on the Wrist? More like the Tap of a FeatherIt was an offer his client couldn't refuse. That's how Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson partner Steven Witzel described the deal offered by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to his client William Tirrell.September 15A Win in the Steinbeck FeudYou might call it a literary success. Susan Kohlmann, managing partner of Jenner & Block's New York office, secured a shutout win for the stepdaughter of John Steinbeck in the latest installment of a long-running legal feud over book rights that has divided the late author's progeny.September 22The Gibson Dunn Duo Who Destroyed the OPM Data Breach MDLGibson, Dunn & Crutcher partners F. Joseph Warin and Jason Mendro won dismissal of a class action over a massive data breach.September 29Who Needs Prep Time? This Litigator of the Week Stepped In Last Minute for Huge Win Against SECWhen Randy Mastro met Lynn Tilton, the "Diva of Distressed" was facing the biggest SEC administrative case of all time--and her trial date was six weeks away. Mastro and his team from Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher defied the odds to win complete vindication.October 6A $1.74B Payout in a Monster of a CaseThey called it “a tale of two Citis.” Representing Lehman Brothers and its creditors committee, Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan partner Andrew Rossman led a team in securing a $1.74 billion settlement from Citigroup on Sept. 29October 13How Teamwork Allowed Plaintiffs’ Lawyers to Pull Off a Nearly $300M AndroGel Double HeaderSeeger Weiss partner David Buchanan and Troy Rafferty, a shareholder at Levin Papantonio Thomas Mitchell Rafferty Proctor, racked up wins in bellwether trials involving AndroGel.October 20A $72M Save in Talc CaseIn the nationwide litigation over talcum powder, Johnson & Johnson turned to Thomas Weaver of Armstrong Teasdale to overturn a $72 million verdict in Missouri. But a lot more was at stake than $72 million.October 27Teamwork Makes the Dream Work in Knocking Out Kasowitz FCA CaseLawyers from five mega-firms came together to fight a $90 billion reverse False Claims Act lawsuit: Christopher Landau of Kirkland & Ellis; Alice Fisher of Latham & Watkins, Raymond Cardozo of Reed Smith, Seth Rosenthal of Venable and William Goodman of Bradley Arant Boult Cummings.November 3Reframing the Independent Contractor FightIn a battle over classifying workers as employees or independent contractors, Gibson Dunn partner Jason Schwartz figured out how to reframe the fight.November 10Kirkland Duo Delivers Big for HoneywellKirkland & Ellis partners K. Winn Allen and Craig Primis successfully defended Honeywell International against a labor contract challenge, wading into an area of case law that even one of the judges called "a mess." Nov. 17Standing Your Ground in the EDTXAgainst the odds, Jennifer Doan of Haltom & Doan, Mark Ferguson of Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott, and David Dolkas of McDermott Will & Emery convinced a jury that Hewlett Packard Enterprise did not infringe a key patent, and that the patent itself was invalid.December 1A Nod for “Trustworthiness” in a Timely Win for UberMichael Li-Ming Wong of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher gave Uber Technologies a sorely needed legal win, securing dismissal of a long-running data breach class action brought on behalf of about 50,000 drivers.December 8Covington Pair Score the Plea Deal Read Round the WorldWhile we may never know what Special Counsel Robert Mueller III had on Michael Flynn, it's hard to imagine a much better deal for the retired general. It’s a testament to the work of his lawyers, a team at Covington & Burling led by partners Robert Kelner and Stephen Anthony.December 15A Mega-Bank Battle With Billion-Dollar ImplicationsShearman & Sterling’s Joseph Frank prevailed on behalf of Japanese financial giant Nomura in a case with hundreds of millions on the line. And the decision by New York’s highest court could save billions for other banks in similar situations.